Should You Invest in ETFs or Should You Invest in Mutual Funds?

Exchange-traded funds and mutual funds have their advantages and disadvantages.

While investors often ponder if they should invest in ETFs or mutual funds, there is no reason to.

Investors can use ETFs as well as mutual funds in appropriate ways to benefit from the advantages of both.

ETF Advantages

  • Transparency: ETFs usually disclose their holdings each day, making it easy for investors to know what they are investing in.
  • Trading flexibility: Investors can buy & sell ETFs through the day whenever the stock market is open.
  • Management expense: ETF expense ratios tend to be lower than mutual fund expense ratios.
  • Tax efficiency: The structure of ETFs may lend themselves to be more tax efficient.

Mutual Fund Advantages

  • Active security selection: Mutual funds can benefit from in-depth research & analysis conducted by money managers to uncover investments with superior risk-adjusted return.
  • Periodic investing: Mutual funds make it easy for investors to invest small amounts without commissions at regular intervals through automatic investment plans.
  • Trading costs: Many no load mutual funds are available without transaction fees in mutual fund networks like Fidelity FundsNetwork or Schwab OneSource.

Invest in ETFs and Mutual Funds to Maximize Benefits

All too often, investors make a mistake by focusing on pre-tax return when comparing investments.

It is difficult to predict with any degree of certainty which of the two … a particular ETF or a comparable mutual fund … would deliver a higher pre-tax return during its holding period.

Investors would be better off focusing on predictable factors like total cost of owning investments and taxes on an account-specific basis as this can improve the odds of maximizing return.

Generally, mutual funds are better suited for smaller-sized accounts while ETFs are better suited for larger-sized accounts.

ETFs are better suited for accounts with a trading objective. Many mutual funds impose penalties or place restrictions to discourage frequent trading.

ETFs are more appropriate for taxable accounts where investors can realize the tax efficiency benefit of ETFs. Mutual funds on the other hand are better suited for tax-deferred accounts.

In sum, one does not have to avoid ETFs simply because one invests in mutual funds and vice versa. Investors have the option of investing in both ETFs and mutual funds. Investors can maximize benefits by including both ETFs and mutual funds in appropriate accounts considering size, investment objective, and tax status.

 

Must-read Articles on ETF Investing

Sector ETFs: Invest in the Best Sector ETF Consistently

Sector ETFs are among the most potent investment vehicles that allow individual investors to exploit advantages previously available only to large institutions. You can beat the market by investing in the right sector ETF at the right time. In fact, you can actually make money even when the overall market is tanking. Read More »

Select Sector SPDRs: Ways to Maximize Return and Minimize Risk

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are growing in popularity. Bucking difficult market conditions, assets invested in ETFs have increased from $569 billion in January 2008 to $693 billion in September 2009. The flexibility provided by Select Sector SPDR ETFs in creating low-cost portfolios with customized asset allocations have enabled them to carve out a niche in the ETF world. Read More »

Best ETFs to Build Your ETF Portfolio

'Don’t put all your eggs in one basket'. This is commonly believed to be a sound investing maxim. Why? Because diversification helps investors to lower risk and to stay on course towards their goals without being derailed by market sell-offs. So, how does one build a diversified portfolio? Read More »

New ETF and Mutual Fund Recommendations

The Fidelity and ETF Core and Focus model portfolios have gained at annualized rates of 14.5% and 17.7%, respectively since 1994. The model portfolios will be repositioned with new mutual fund and ETF recommendations on Tuesday, December 31. Learn more about AlphaProfit's Free and Premium Service investment newsletters.

Recent MoneyMatters Blog Posts